Race Factor in Newborns Study


 An interesting new study was published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Science by Brad Greenwood, Rachel Hardeman, Laura Haung, and Aaron Sojourner showing that black babies have lower mortality rates when treated by MDs that are also black. Lets first talk about the two major headlines I saw when this study came out.

            CNN wrote: “Black newborns more likely to die when looked after White doctors.” In this article they point out some key conclusions made during this study, first being that mortality rates for white babies were largely unaffected by the doctor’s race. Second being that the study found that “when cared for by White physicians, Black newborns were about three times more likely to die in the hospital than white newborns.” CNN also included a quote from the co-author of the publication, Rachel Hardeman, from twitter: “Our study provides the first evidence that the Black-White newborn mortality gap is smaller when Black MDs provide care for Black newborns than when White MDs do, lending support to research examining the importance of racial concordance in addressing health care inequities.”

            Fox News wrote: “Black babies see higher odds of survival with Black doctors’ care: Study.” Very similar writing in both articles, but Fox News did include that the benefits of same-race newborn and MD’s particularly in Black babies were more evident in complicated cases with challenging births, and also in hospitals that deliver more black babies. Fox News also added that researches did not find any great improvement in maternal death in the correlation of MDs sharing the same race as the mother. 

            Let me start off by saying, that the CNN article would probably have caught for more eyes as the headline was far more gruesome than that of Fox News. The main topic to note is that this study was conducted on specifically Florida hospitals and another thing, in hospitals with greater Black baby deliveries, which is something CNN failed to mention. CNN also did not mention anything about maternal death in their article. The other information in both articles are basically identical besides that CNN chose to include that our health system is showing racial injustice just within the first hours of life. This is not a topic that one could disagree with or agree with because it is backed by facts and data. That being said, from what I was able to read of the actual publication of this study without paying $10, I began to question a couple of things. This study was based on Florida hospitals, many of which statistically birth more Black babies, and many of the cases studied were pertaining to complicated births. Could environment of the mother have an impact on this data? Is there a possible genetic reason that complicated or challenging childbirths have lower survival rates other than race? Does this data and statistics hold true throughout the entire U.S or even all over the world? Will there be any progressions in this study to find out? In no way is this blog intended to question whether racial injustice is a factor in Black newborn survival, my intention is to question whether there are other factors that could play into these abnormal mortality rates.


Sources:


https://www.cnn.com/2020/08/18/health/black-babies-mortality-rate-doctors-study-wellness-scli-intl/index.html


https://www.foxnews.com/health/black-babies-higher-survival-black-doctor


https://www.pnas.org/content/early/2020/08/12/1913405117

Comments

  1. Olivia,
    I really enjoyed reading this blog post! I have never heard of this study and found it to be very enlightening. I plan on reading both articles and comparing! I do agree that there is racial injustices whether that be from the medical pov or the justice system. It was no surprise that one article didn't contain factual information, however I was surprised to see that they did address the socioeconomic class in which the hospital was in. With your questions of genetic issues, complicated births, and maternal problems , am I curious to see if the level of income in the area played a factor in the infant morality rates. What is your take on that? -- Hannah W.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This is also a great factor that I would love to see information on in this study. I think it is definitely something that could contribute, but from what I was able to read, I am unaware of this being a variable in this particular study!

      Delete
  2. I saw this article as well and was a little shocked by the headline and the information. From what you have said and what I have seen myself, I think more questions need to be answered in order to come to this conclusion. While I agree that racial injustice in health care absolutely needs more attention and action, I don't think that alone is sufficient to conclude that black babies die at a higher rate due to the race of the doctor. I think we need to ask more questions like you mentioned, prior complications or issues, maternal health, and the overall health of the baby post delivery before receiving care. Hopefully some journalists will do a little more digging to find more data to support or reject this idea. Great post overall, very enjoyable!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular Posts